Claims and Payments American Modern Claims: 800-375-2075Payments: 800-543-2644 Badger Mutual Claims: 800-837-7833Payments: 800-837-7833 Bristol West Claims: 800-274-7865Payments: Capitol Insurance Group Claims: 800-986-9974Payments: 800-682-9255 Encompass Claims: 800-588-7400Payments: 866-430-2916 The Hartford Claims: 860-547-5000Payments: 860-547-5000 Infinity Claims: 800-353-6737Payments: 800-782-1020 Mendota Insurance Claims: 800-422-0793Payments: 800-422-0792 Mercury Insurance Claims: 800-503-3724Payments: 800-503-3724 Progressive Claims: 800-776-4737Payments: 800-888-7764 Safeco Insurance Claims: 800-332-3226Payments: 888-726-3260 Travelers Insurance Claims: 800-252-4633Payments: 877-878-2468 Dairyland Claims: 800-334-0090Payments: 800-334-0090 Kemper Claims: 888-253-7834Payments: 800-456-0448 Liberty Mutual Claims: 844-629-8984 Payments: 800-290-8102 Cincinnati Insurance Claims: 877-242-2544Payments: 800-364-3400 Berkshire Hathaway Guard Claims: 888-639-2567Payments: 800-673-2465 Foremost Claims: 800-237-6136Payments: 800-532-4221 Stillwater Claims: 800-220-1351 Payments: 800-220-1351 Homeowners of America Claims: 866-407-9896 Payments: 866-407-9896 Hippo Claims: 855-999-9746 Payments: 800-585-0705 Lemonade ClaimsPayments Pie Insurance Claims: 844-581-0828Payments Hagerty Claims: 888-220-9565 Payments: 800-762-2628 American Strategic Insurance Claims: 866-274-5677Payments: 866-274-8765 Markel Claims: 800-362-7535Payments: 888-642-4968 Hiscox Claims: 866-424-8508 Payments: 888-202-3007 National General Premier Claims: 844-287-2236Payments: 844-287-2237 Farmers Claims: 800-435-7764Payments: 888-327-6335 Trexis Claims: 877-384-7466Payments: 877-384-7466 Universal North America Insurance Claims: 866-999-0898Payments: 866-458-4262 BiBerk Claims: 844-472-0967 Payments: 844-472-0967